Cheddar (38)

Search Results

• 724 Wisconsin Select 15 Year White Cheddar Cheese, 4.9 Ounce, $14.19

  Hand selected cheddar by a 2nd generation Wisconsin Licensed Cheese Grader Number 724. Aged for 15 years, this extra sharp cheddar reaches the pinnacle of craftmanship; its rich, unique and captivating. Savor the crunchy amino acid crystals which form during the aging process - a nice contrast to the milk's natural rich, smoothness. Pairings: Honey, hot honey, spicy honey mustard, charcuterie, Champagne or Prosecco. No gluten ingredients. GMO free. Made in Wisconsin from cow's milk.

  724 Wisconsin Select

  

  Add 724 Wisconsin Select 15 Year White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add 724 Wisconsin Select 15 Year White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Gluten Free

  Non GMO

  Minimally Processed

  724 Wisconsin Select 15 Year White Cheddar Cheese, 4.9 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $14.19

  $2.90/oz

  Add to Cart

• 724 Wisconsin Select Harmony White Cheddar Cheese, 4.9 Ounce, $12.19

  Sweet, fruity and buttery. Grand Symphony of sweet fruity cheddar and hints of sweet parmesan and buttery gouda.

  724 Wisconsin Select

  

  Add 724 Wisconsin Select Harmony White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add 724 Wisconsin Select Harmony White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  724 Wisconsin Select Harmony White Cheddar Cheese, 4.9 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $12.19

  $2.49/oz

  Add to Cart

• Barber's 1833 Vintage Reserve Cheddar Cheese, 6.7 Ounce, $8.19

  Barber's 1833 Vintage Reserve is always matured for a minimum of two years to provide a cheddar that is powerfully intense and complex with an exceptional depth of flavor. It has a creamy texture and smooth finish and contains naturally occurring crystals that give it a distinctive crunch. The Barber family, who are the oldest cheddar-making family in the world, are situated in Southwest of England, only 15 miles from the Village of Cheddar itself. Cheddar making is beyond a passion, it is their life's work.

  Barber's Farmhouse

  

  Add Barber's 1833 Vintage Reserve Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Barber's 1833 Vintage Reserve Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Barber's 1833 Vintage Reserve Cheddar Cheese, 6.7 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $8.19

  $1.22/oz

  Add to Cart

• Black Diamond Grand Reserve White Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $12.99/lb

  Aged over 2 years, this popular Canadian cheddar has a sharp, robust and tangy flavor. Serve a slice on toasted buttered rye bread. Made from unpasteurized cow milk.

  Black Diamond

  Deal

  

  Add Black Diamond Grand Reserve White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Black Diamond Grand Reserve White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Black Diamond Grand Reserve White Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $12.99/lb

  $12.99/lb

  was $18.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Carr Valley Baby Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $19.19/lb

  Classic cheddar handmade in central Wisconsin and aged only 30-60 days. Mild cheddar flavors with a moist texture. Slice and add to sandwiches or enjoy with beef summer sausage. Beer Pairings: Pilsner or American Lager Wine Pairing: Sauvignon Blanc. Made from cow's milk.

  Carr Valley Cheese

  

  Add Carr Valley Baby Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Carr Valley Baby Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Carr Valley Baby Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $19.19/lb

  $19.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Carr Valley Chipotle Cranberry Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $22.19/lb

  A white Cheddar that combines with cranberries and chipotle peppers for some added depth. The result is the spicy taste of a Texas barbecue sauce, with the nice warm finish coming on after the mild Cheddar flavor. Try this one during the cooler autumn months. It will melt beautifully on those grilled paninis or in any recipe. Wine pairing: Think about a crisp Rose. Made in Wisconsin from cows milk.

  Carr Valley Cheese

  

  Add Carr Valley Chipotle Cranberry Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Carr Valley Chipotle Cranberry Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Carr Valley Chipotle Cranberry Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $22.19/lb

  $22.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Clawson Cotswold Gloucester Cheese, 1 Pound, $24.19/lb

  A delicious blend of smooth double Gloucester, onion, and a sprinkling of fresh chives. Made from pasteurized cows milk. Product of the UK.

  Clawson

  

  Add Clawson Cotswold Gloucester Cheese to Favorites.Add Clawson Cotswold Gloucester Cheese to Favorites.

  Clawson Cotswold Gloucester Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $24.19/lb

  $24.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Clawson Huntsman Cheese, 1 Pound, $28.19/lb

  Hand-finished Huntsman is comprised of two layers of Double Gloucester with a ring of Blue Stilton sandwiched in between. It makes a perfect centerpiece for a cheeseboard.

  Clawson

  

  Add Clawson Huntsman Cheese to Favorites.Add Clawson Huntsman Cheese to Favorites.

  Clawson Huntsman Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $28.19/lb

  $28.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Deer Creek The Robin Colby Cheese, 1 Pound, $17.19/lb

  Award winning buttery classic, handmade Wisconsin Original Colby. Firm, yet open and curdy body combined with a fresh buttery taste and a pleasantly salty finish. Enjoy with Apples, Strawberries, Buttery Crackers, Peanuts, Cashews, Ham, Summer Sausage. Pairs well with Domestic Beers, Ales, Lagers and Malbec, Pinot Noir, Cabernet Sauvignon.

  Deer Creek

  

  Add Deer Creek The Robin Colby Cheese to Favorites.Add Deer Creek The Robin Colby Cheese to Favorites.

  Deer Creek The Robin Colby Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $17.19/lb

  $17.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Deer Creek The Wild Boar Monterey Jack Cheese, 1 Pound, $26.19/lb

  Earthy black truffle ambles between creamy Monterey Jack curds to craft the decadent yet approachable sensory experience that is The Wild Boar. Each bite transports your palate to the Wisconsin North with the savory truffles' warm and woodsy notes coupled with mild, buttery cheese. This charming and aromatic Jack easily finds its home on a board or melted into dishes for a delightfully mushroomy finish.

  The Wild Boar

  

  Add Deer Creek The Wild Boar Monterey Jack Cheese to Favorites.Add Deer Creek The Wild Boar Monterey Jack Cheese to Favorites.

  Gluten Free

  Dairy Free

  Deer Creek The Wild Boar Monterey Jack Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $26.19/lb

  $26.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Deer Creek Vat 17 Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $25.19/lb

  A Wisconsin artisan cheddar cheese with a distinct tangy and nutty flavor. Pair with cashews, dried apricots or cherries, pistachios or crusty artisan bread. Made for beer pairing- try bock, lagers, brown ales of hard ciders. Aged for at least 2 years. Winner of numerous national and international cheese awards.

  Deer Creek

  

  Add Deer Creek Vat 17 Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Deer Creek Vat 17 Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Deer Creek Vat 17 Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $25.19/lb

  $25.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Deer Creek Vat 17 Cheddar Cheese, 6 Ounce, $10.19

  A Wisconsin artisan cheddar cheese with a distinct tangy and nutty flavor. Pair with cashews, dried apricots or cherries, pistachios or crusty artisan bread. Made for beer pairing- try bock, lagers, brown ales of hard ciders. Aged for at least 2 years. Winner of numerous national and international cheese awards.

  Deer Creek

  

  Add Deer Creek Vat 17 Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Deer Creek Vat 17 Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Minimally Processed

  Deer Creek Vat 17 Cheddar Cheese, 6 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $10.19

  $1.70/oz

  Add to Cart

• Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery White Cheddar Cheese Curds, 16 Ounce, $8.99

  These cheddar cheese curds are the freshest form of cheddar cheese available. The squeaky fresh, mild, bite-sized cheese curds make a great snack. Crafted using the highest quality rBST free milk from 450 family farms throughout Minnesota and Wisconsin. High in calcium and protein. No added sugars. No carbs. No Trans fat. No gluten ingredients.

  Ellsworth

  

  Add Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery White Cheddar Cheese Curds to Favorites.Add Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery White Cheddar Cheese Curds to Favorites.

  Gluten Free

  No Added Sugar

  Minimally Processed

  Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery White Cheddar Cheese Curds, 16 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $8.99

  $0.56/oz

  Add to Cart

• Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery White Cheddar Cheese Curds, 5 Ounce, $3.69

  These cheddar cheese curds are the freshest form of cheddar cheese available. The squeaky fresh, mild, bite-sized cheese curds make a great snack. Crafted using the highest quality rBST free milk from 450 family farms throughout Minnesota and Wisconsin. High in calcium and protein. No added sugars. No carbs. No Trans fat. No gluten ingredients.

  Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery

  

  Add Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery White Cheddar Cheese Curds to Favorites.Add Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery White Cheddar Cheese Curds to Favorites.

  Gluten Free

  Minimally Processed

  Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery White Cheddar Cheese Curds, 5 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $3.69

  $0.74/oz

  Add to Cart

• Hook's 10 Year Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $40.19/lb

  A Wisconsin aged cheddar which won first place at the 2006 American Cheese Society Show. Loaded with calcium crystals, its full, rich cheddar flavor and ultimately smooth finish make this cheese a cheese board standout. Made from cow's milk. Women-owned business.

  Hook's Cheese Company

  

  Add Hook's 10 Year Sharp Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Hook's 10 Year Sharp Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Hook's 10 Year Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $40.19/lb

  $40.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Kaukauna Sharp Cheddar with Almonds Cheese Ball Spread, 6 Ounce, $5.69

  Kaukauna Sharp Cheddar Cheese Ball is made with real Wisconsin aged cheddar cheese and covered in slivered almonds that will satisfy everyone's cravings. A delicious combination of flavor and texture. Serve it any time of the year as an easy appetizer on a cheese platter, paired with your favorite crackers, meats, fruits and veggies or enjoy as a delicious snack with crackers or pretzels. No artificial flavors.

  Kaukauna

  

  Add Kaukauna Sharp Cheddar with Almonds Cheese Ball Spread to Favorites.Add Kaukauna Sharp Cheddar with Almonds Cheese Ball Spread to Favorites.

  Kaukauna Sharp Cheddar with Almonds Cheese Ball Spread, 6 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $5.69

  $0.95/oz

  Add to Cart

• Kerrygold Dubliner Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $15.99/lb

  Dubliner is a sweet mature cheese (aged over twelve months). The cheese is named after the city of Dublin. It is made in Cork however, and has a robust flavor, with a light distinctive tang. It combines the sharpness of mature cheddar, the nuttiness of Swiss, and piquant bite of Parmesan. The cheese was developed by Irishman John Lucey and this secret recipe is exclusively held by the company Carbery. Dubliner may contain natural calcium lactate crystals, these appear as small white pieces. The flavor is best preserved by keeping it in a well-sealed container and refrigerated. It does not do well after freezing. An hour before eating, pull the from the refrigerator. It pairs well with apples and grapes, or a well-balanced red wine.

  Kerrygold

  Deal

  

  Add Kerrygold Dubliner Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Kerrygold Dubliner Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Kerrygold Dubliner Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $15.99/lb

  $15.99/lb

  was $19.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Kerrygold Dubliner Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce, $7.49

  Dubliner is a sweet mature cheese (aged over twelve months). The cheese is named after the city of Dublin. It is made in Cork however, and has a robust flavour, with a light distinctive tang; it pairs well with apples and grapes, or a well-balanced red wine. It combines the sharpness of mature cheddar, the nuttiness of Swiss, and piquant bite of Parmesan. The cheese was developed by Irishman John Lucey and this secret recipe is exclusively held by the company Carbery. Dubliner may contain natural calcium lactate crystals, these appear as small white pieces. The flavour of Dubliner cheese is best preserved by keeping it in a well-sealed container and refrigerated. It does not do well after freezing. An hour before eating, pull the Dubliner cheese from the refrigerator.

  Kerrygold

  Deal

  

  Add Kerrygold Dubliner Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Kerrygold Dubliner Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Gluten Free

  Minimally Processed

  Kerrygold Dubliner Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $7.49

  $1.07/oz

  was $9.19

  Add to Cart

• L&B Early Bird Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $12.19/lb

  Exclusively available at Lunds & Byerlys, Early Bird Cheddar Cheese is a handcrafted celebration of simplicity, flavor and tradition. Made from fresh, pasteurized cow's milk sourced from small local family farms, this 5-month aged cheddar delivers a clean, creamy richness with every bite. Developed over four generations by dedicated family cheesemakers, its smooth texture is complemented by a touch of nuttiness and a slightly sweet finish. Whether paired with crisp apple slices, drizzled with local honey on our Flatbread Bites or enjoyed on its own, Early Bird Cheddar is a versatile favorite. Made with milk from cows that pasture-graze and are never treated with rBST.

  Lunds & Byerlys

  

  Add L&B Early Bird Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add L&B Early Bird Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  L&B Early Bird Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $12.19/lb

  $12.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Maple Leaf Cranberry White Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $14.19/lb

  The rich, nutty flavor of the white cheddar cheese is the perfect opposite of the sweetness of the cranberries to give your taste buds an explosion of flavor with every bite. Maple Leaf cheddar cheeses are double milled curd production cheddar as opposed to stirred curd to most resemble traditional cheddar production, texture and flavor. Made with pasteurized cow's milk. Handcrafted in Wisconsin.

  Lunds & Byerlys

  

  Add Maple Leaf Cranberry White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Maple Leaf Cranberry White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Maple Leaf Cranberry White Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $14.19/lb

  $14.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Milton Creamery 4 Alarm Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $14.19/lb

  Unique blend of chipotle peppers, jalapeno peppers, chili peppers and ghost peppers in a creamy cheddar. Deliciously balanced and packed with layers of flavor with a spicy heat at the end. Try it on a hamburger, grated over taco or enjoy it with crackers. Made in Iowa from pasteurized cow's milk.

  Milton Creamery

  

  Add Milton Creamery 4 Alarm Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Milton Creamery 4 Alarm Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Milton Creamery 4 Alarm Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $14.19/lb

  $14.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Milton Creamery Prairie Breeze Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $20.19/lb

  Award-winning artisan white cheddar cheese aged for a minimum of 9 months. Sweeter than a typical cheddar. Creamy, yet crumbly texture with a slight crunch from calcium crystals developed during aging. Excellent melting cheese for burgers, sandwiches, macaroni and cheese. Slice and serve with apple pie, chocolate chip cookies or multi grain crackers. Made in Iowa from cow milk.

  Milton Creamery

  

  Add Milton Creamery Prairie Breeze Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Milton Creamery Prairie Breeze Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Milton Creamery Prairie Breeze Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $20.19/lb

  $20.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Oscar Wilde Aged Irish Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $20.19/lb

  Rich, nutty, and distinctively creamy with a firm, smooth texture. Named after the famous Irish poet and made from milk from pasture grazed cows. It finishes with a playful, tangy bite. Enjoy on cheeseboards and with soups and salad. Product of Ireland.

  Oscar Wild

  

  Add Oscar Wilde Aged Irish Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Oscar Wilde Aged Irish Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Oscar Wilde Aged Irish Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $20.19/lb

  $20.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart

• Sartori Cherrywood Smoked Cheddar Cheese, 5 Ounce, $6.69

  Sartori's MontAmore smooth and creamy Cheddar is naturally smoked, creating a symphony of sweet smoky notes. Savory meats like ribs and bacon and sweet fruits like dates and dried cherries pair well with this smoked cheddar. Sip on a glass of red or white wine, a light beer or a crisp sparkling water while snacking. Made in Wisconsin from cow's milk.

  Sartori

  

  Add Sartori Cherrywood Smoked Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Sartori Cherrywood Smoked Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Minimally Processed

  Sartori Cherrywood Smoked Cheddar Cheese, 5 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $6.69

  $1.34/oz

  Add to Cart

• Sartori Farmhouse Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce, $6.69

  Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar is extra-sharp and rich, delivering a perfect combination of sharp, savory, and buttery notes. Wine Pairings: Pinot Grigio, Bordeaux Blanc, Cote du Rhone, Tempranillo. Beer and Hard Cider Pairings: Brown ale, citrus IPA, semi-dry hard cider. Food pairings: Dried fruit, apples, warm apple pie, sesame crackers, pita chips, currant preservies, Italian sopressata cured meat and summer sausage. Made in Wisconsin from pasteurized cow's milk by Master Cheesemaker Pam Hodgson. Family-owned business.

  Sartori

  

  Add Sartori Farmhouse Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Sartori Farmhouse Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Minimally Processed

  Sartori Farmhouse Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $6.69

  $0.96/oz

  Add to Cart

• Sartori Italian Herb Cheddar Cheese Bites, 4.5 Ounce, $4.99

  A bold twist on classic cheddar, Sartori Italian Herb Cheddar Cheese Bites deliver sharp, aged white cheddar infused with a perfectly balanced blend of Italian herbs. Each bite-sized wheel is crafted to bring a rich, savory flavor experience, ideal for those who love the aromatic warmth of basil, oregano and rosemary combined with the creamy texture of Sartori's award-winning cheddar. Individually wrapped for on-the-go snacking, these cheese bites are perfect for lunchboxes, road trips or an easy addition to a charcuterie board. Made in Wisconsin from cow's milk. Family-owned business. 6 - 0.75-ounce wheels per package.

  Sartori

  Deal

  

  Add Sartori Italian Herb Cheddar Cheese Bites to Favorites.Add Sartori Italian Herb Cheddar Cheese Bites to Favorites.

  Minimally Processed

  Sartori Italian Herb Cheddar Cheese Bites, 4.5 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $4.99

  $1.11/oz

  was $6.19

  Add to Cart

• Sartori Montamore Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce, $6.69

  Sweet, creamy, fruity artisan cheese with a tangy finish. Pair with chocolate, crusty bread, nuts, dried pineapple or green olives. Pale ales, stout, porter or bocks are excellent beer accompaniments. Pairs well with wines such as; beaujolais, Chardonnays, light Italian reds or Pinot Noirs. Made in Wisconsin from cow's milk. Family-owned business.

  Sartori

  

  Add Sartori Montamore Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Sartori Montamore Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Minimally Processed

  Sartori Montamore Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $6.69

  $0.96/oz

  Add to Cart

• Sartori MontAmore Cheddar Cheese Bites, 4.5 Ounce, $4.99

  Elevate your snacking experience with Sartori MontAmore Cheddar Cheese Bites, a delightful balance of creamy texture and bold, complex flavor. Each bite-sized wheel is crafted with Sartori's award-winning MontAmore Cheddar, known for its smooth, white cheddar base and unexpectedly tangy parmesan notes. Perfectly portioned for on-the-go convenience, these individually wrapped cheese bites are an effortless way to enjoy premium artisanal cheese wherever your day takes you. Made in Wisconsin from cow's milk. Family-owned business. 6 - 0.75-ounce wheels per package.

  Sartori

  Deal

  

  Add Sartori MontAmore Cheddar Cheese Bites to Favorites.Add Sartori MontAmore Cheddar Cheese Bites to Favorites.

  Minimally Processed

  Sartori MontAmore Cheddar Cheese Bites, 4.5 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $4.99

  $1.11/oz

  was $6.19

  Add to Cart

• Sartori Old World Sharp White Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce, $6.69

  Features an incredible flavor that profiles sweet, savory notes and finishes with a buttery touch. Delightfully sharp notes highlight and brighten this robust, full of flavor white cheddar. Pair with Fuji apples, almonds, baguettes or cherry preserves. Beverage pairings: Malbec, Pinot Noir, IPAs, and stouts. Established in 1939, Sartori is a family owned, fourth generation, high quality cheese manufacturer located in Plymouth, Wisconsin. Their rBST-free cow's milk comes from local, family owned and run farms and is tested at every drop for quality. Family-owned business.

  Sartori

  

  Add Sartori Old World Sharp White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Sartori Old World Sharp White Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Minimally Processed

  Sartori Old World Sharp White Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce

  Open Product Description

  $6.69

  $0.96/oz

  Add to Cart

• Somerdale Red Dragon Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound, $20.19/lb

  Creamy English cheddar is carefully blended with wholegrain mustard seed and Ale providing a wonderful bite without being overpowering. Red Dragon is a great addition to any cheese board and makes for a fantastic burger topping or grilled sandwich filling.

  Somerdale

  

  Add Somerdale Red Dragon Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.Add Somerdale Red Dragon Cheddar Cheese to Favorites.

  Somerdale Red Dragon Cheddar Cheese, 1 Pound

  Open Product Description

  $20.19/lb

  $20.19/lb

  Final cost based on weight

  Add to Cart